✨ Your message has been delivered successfully. Thank you.
Recep Songül

Speaking—or Being Unable to Speak

The Reasons for Silence and the Responsibility to Bear Witness to the Truth

Speaking—or Being Unable to Speak

Sometimes people remain silent not because they have nothing to say, but because they fear the consequences of what they might say. They are unable to speak not because they do not know the truth, but because they fear the cost of acting upon the truth they know. Losing their position, being deprived of anticipated benefits, facing disruption to their work, encountering obstacles, being excluded from certain circles, or no longer being invited into familiar settings… All these can become invisible barriers to saying what one believes to be right. Some fear being seen as dissenting or harsh; others fear being targeted for criticising the current course of events; still others hesitate to face the smears and losses suffered by those who spoke before them. Thus, words whose truth is clear to a person’s conscience become difficult to utter. The real issue is not to speak on every subject, but to avoid remaining silent when speech is necessary, and not to sacrifice the truth to personal calculations when it needs defending.

Silence is rarely defended openly; instead, it is cloaked in seemingly reasonable justifications. “Now is not the time,” “The circumstances are not right,” “We will be misunderstood,” “Others are already speaking,” or “What difference would it make if we spoke?” Of course, speech has its proper time, criticism its proper manner, and struggle its need for wisdom. Saying everything one knows in every setting is not an act of responsibility. Yet we must not confuse wisdom with timidity, prudence with fear, or the common good with personal advantage. Is silence on a particular matter genuinely being chosen to prevent greater harm, or to preserve existing relationships and opportunities? This is a question people must first put to their own conscience. Wisdom does not mean abandoning the truth; it means having the resolve to defend it in appropriate language, in a suitable setting, and with due regard for the consequences.

Speaking may come at a cost. Those who voice what they believe to be right may sometimes find themselves alone, see their relationships damaged, or have doors closed in their faces; they may face unjust accusations and smear campaigns. It would be wrong to dismiss these costs or expect people to bear burdens beyond their capacity. Yet silence, too, has a cost—one that concerns not only the individual but society as a whole. When wrongdoing is continually overlooked, it becomes normalised; when left unchallenged, it gradually becomes the rule. People learn to stand close to the powerful rather than the just, and to shape their stance according to circumstances rather than principles. Eventually, it is not the person who speaks but the very act of speaking that seems strange. A person who speaks may pay a personal price, but universal silence erodes society’s sense of justice and its future.

In an environment where fewer people speak the truth, the words of the few who point out wrongdoing resonate widely. People hear, in their voices, objections they themselves carry within but cannot express; they value these individuals’ courage and consistency. Such appreciation is understandable and important. Yet the fact that a small number of politicians, scholars, or community leaders speak out does not mean that the responsibility has been fulfilled. A political figure’s occasional truthful and courageous statements may be valuable, but society’s entire moral responsibility cannot be delegated to a handful of statements or individuals. Nor does the scarcity of those who voice the truth require us to accept everything they say without question. When a truth is rarely spoken, the person who voices it gains visibility; this does not justify society’s silence.

One of the greatest tests concerning truth and justice lies in our affiliations. If we find excuses for wrongdoing by those on our side while fiercely condemning the same wrongdoing by others, we have lost our moral bearings. Being close to a political organisation does not require approving every decision it makes; belonging to an institution does not require defending all its practices; respecting a scholar does not place every opinion they hold beyond criticism. Likewise, acknowledging a truth spoken by someone with whom we disagree does not mean abandoning our own values. The Qur’anic command to “stand firmly for justice, bearing witness for Allah, even against yourselves, your parents, or your close relatives” (An-Nisa, 4:135) reminds us of the test justice faces when those close to us are involved. The command, “Do not let hatred of a people lead you to act unjustly” (Al-Ma’idah, 5:8), reveals the test it faces in relation to distance and opposition. What is right remains right, whoever it comes from; what is wrong remains wrong, whoever commits it. Sincere loyalty means seeking to correct wrongdoing when necessary, not covering it up.

This responsibility rests particularly upon scholars, intellectuals, educators, and civil society organisations. Their purpose is not merely to follow developments, organise events, or issue statements in response to the political agenda. They are expected to guide society through knowledge and ethics, make what is right visible in the face of wrongdoing, and, when necessary, warn those within their own circles. Political organisations set agendas, train their members, develop narratives, and influence society in pursuit of their objectives. Islamic scholarly circles, civic organisations, and independent intellectuals must bring their own intellectual and moral influence to bear with at least the same seriousness. Civil society must become a social force that speaks from its own principles and accumulated knowledge, rather than a body that merely endorses politics from its shadow. This does not mean hostility towards politics or the constant generation of conflict; it means preserving independence, offering support when appropriate, issuing warnings when necessary, and keeping principle at the centre in every circumstance.

At this point, the manner of criticism matters just as much as its substance. Defending the truth does not mean escalating every issue, humiliating people, or making existing difficulties worse. We must distinguish sincere counsel from public exposure, reform from destructiveness, and principled objection from personal score-settling. The Qur’an’s instruction to Moses and Aaron to speak gently even to Pharaoh (Ta-Ha, 20:44) shows that truth need not be expressed without courtesy. Depending on the circumstances, a clear public statement, direct counsel, a scholarly assessment, or an institutional initiative may be more effective. Yet caution in method must not turn into abandonment of principle. Courtesy must not weaken the truth; nor should the claim to defend the truth eliminate courtesy and justice.

Another grave consequence of persistent silence is the example it leaves to future generations. Young people see not only what their elders say, but also what they avoid saying. A young person raised in an environment where remaining silent in the face of wrongdoing, adjusting one’s position to powerful circles, and postponing principles to avoid losing relationships are considered normal will struggle to see integrity as life’s defining standard. They begin to think that influence matters more than knowledge and ethics, connections more than merit, and calculation more than being right. This is therefore not merely a question of making a statement or raising an objection today; it is a question of the example of character we leave to our families, students, and society. Some of the opportunities we think we preserve through silence today cannot compensate for the moral courage our children may lose tomorrow.

The Qur’an calls upon the Muslim community to be witnesses over humanity (Al-Baqarah, 2:143). Bearing witness is not merely knowing what is right or listing other people’s wrongs; it means joining knowledge with justice, speech with responsibility, and criticism with ethics. Not everyone has the same circumstances or resources; no one can be expected to speak on every subject with the same force or in the same way. Yet scholars must ask which truth their knowledge serves; thinkers, which truth their thought serves; and civil society organisations, which truth their institutional existence serves. An institution’s strength is measured not only by the size of its gatherings, the officials it can reach, or the programmes it organises, but also by its independence and credibility in defending the truth when necessary. Society needs not a voice of constant objection, but a moral stance capable of saying “this is wrong” when necessary, standing alongside what is right, producing solutions, and doing all this even in relation to its own circle.

Ultimately, the issue is not a simple choice between speaking and remaining silent; it is a question of what we defend, why we defend it, and for whom. The silence of the majority does not turn wrongdoing into right, nor does the small number of those who speak remove our responsibility. Instead of finding consolation in the courage of a few, we should reflect on why our scholarly and intellectual circles, civil society, and institutions are unable to speak with sufficient independence and influence. While political organisations exert a powerful influence over society, those who ought to speak in the name of truth, justice, ethics, and knowledge must not leave their own sphere empty. We become trustworthy to the extent that we can judge both the wrongdoing of those on our side and the truth spoken by those outside it with equal fairness. Knowing the truth is an opportunity; speaking it is a responsibility; standing beside it while recognising the cost, yet refusing to yield to that cost, is a matter of character. Perhaps the first question we should ask ourselves is this: Are we truly unable to speak, or do we choose silence because we cannot bring ourselves to face the price of speaking?

Source: Haksöz Haber — “Konuş(a)mamak,” Recep Songül, 21 October 2026